Grid unprepared for wind, solar power

by PAUL MORDEN, Sarnia Observer

Hydro One has been told to get a move on upgrading transmission lines in southwestern Ontario so more wind and other renewable energy projects can come online.

Ontario’s Energy Ministry has told Hydro One “to move forward immediately” on building a new transmission line and upgrading existing ones west of London.

“Ontarians want a cleaner energy system and we’re moving forward with that,” Energy Minister Brad Duguid said in a press release.

The government’s Long-Term Energy Plan calls for the spending of $2 billion on transmission grid upgrades, including three southwestern Ontario projects the plan says should be in place by 2017 to make room for new green energy projects.

The upgrades and new line west of London are to be completed by 2014, according to the plan.

The minister’s spokesperson Andrew Block said Hydro One will work with the Ontario Power Authority to “start planning out the scope and timing of all those projects.

“That work begins immediately.”

Hydro One spokesperson Daniele Guavin said, “Near term efforts will focus on work such as engineering studies to get a better sense of the characteristics of options for the projects.”

But, one wind energy critic in Lambton County thinks Ontario is getting ahead of itself.

Ann Towell, a member of the Dawn-Euphemia anti-wind group, said the government should wait until legal challenges by wind opponents in Prince Edward County and Chatham-Kent are settled.

“I think they’re going ahead without thinking,” Towell said.

“What if the courts decide there should be a moratorium?”

Towell said she also questions why Ontario would decide to halt plans to build wind turbines in the Great Lakes and continue with land-based projects.

“There are major concerns where those things are.”

A dozen proposed wind farm projects for Lambton are currently waiting in line for contracts to sell power, as well as provincial approvals and space on the transmission grid.

There have also been challenges for the province’s move to encourage individual landowners to connect small scale solar panel projects to the transmission system.

Don McGugan, mayor of Brooke-Alvinston Township, said he just learned a small solar panel project he planned for his farm can’t go ahead now because of lack of room on the grid.

McGugan said he was told by the deputy energy minister recently that improvements would happen “in the very near future” in the west of London region.

“Well, ‘the very near future’ in government terms is 10 years,” McGugan said.

The ministry said in its announcement that Hydro One has also been told to immediately begin upgrading key transformer station to allow small-scale energy projects to connect to the grid.

The ministry also said the Ontario Power Authority will move forward shortly to award the next round of renewable energy contracts.

The province wants to increase the renewable power supply from sources like wind, solar and bio-energy by 10%.

Ontario currently has more than 800 wind turbines, according to the ministry, including 10 operating near Forest.

The ministry’s moves were applauded by Robert Hornung, president of the Canadian Wind Energy Association.

“Proceeding quickly with new contracts for wind energy projects and necessary transmission system upgrades will strengthen investor confidence that Ontario is a good place to do business.”

14 thoughts on “Grid unprepared for wind, solar power

  1. Yup, Hornung of CanWEA is happier than hell — as long as taxpayers foot the $2 BILLION price tag for the transmission lines.

  2. Wow 2 Billion MORE. Out of control spending and building in my opinion. No money no build. Has there been a suggestion to stop the building or spending? Where are the funds coming from??

  3. And the last line is a real choker: “…Ontario is a good place to do business.”

    I think he means “as long as you’re a member of cash-sucking, good-for-nothing CanWEA, otherwise you won’t be able to afford the monthly electricity bills and will be forced to pack up and leave the province.”

  4. “Ontarians want a cleaner energy system and we’re moving forward with that,”

    Do we Brad? Next time you spew your venom, why don’t you sum up in no uncertain terms what the true cost will be for us to get what “we want”? And I’m not just talking numbers here.

    Tell more please, and I can guarantee you, that Ontarians will NOT be so inviting.

    And please, substantiate your rhetoric with some actual CREDIBLE information for once.

  5. Quote: “Proceeding quickly with new contracts for wind energy projects and necessary transmission system upgrades will strengthen investor confidence that Ontario is a good place to do business.”
    Again, where is the money coming from? You can only get so much out of people.
    It’s pretty simple don’t build the turbines and you won’t need transmission lines. You can only spend so much on something before you wind up broke. Get it? Anybody listening? Remember EVERY billion and EVERY trillion has to be paid by someone. Guess who? It’s definitely not free.

  6. The difference between a “brown- out” and a “burn- out”….. one is caused by a provincial government….the other belongs to a provincial government.

  7. Stop The Insanity!…………no wonder the Middle East is blowing apart…dicators are now on a hit list!

    It’s starting over in North America as I type…Wisconsin is the beginning of the “pissed off people” showing some backbone!

  8. I would say “unprepared for anything” and leave it at that.

    In case people have not seen this before… I saw this on WUWT tonight

    Charles S. Opalek, PE says:
    February 18, 2011 at 2:36 pm

    Wind power besides being unreliable and undispatchable, is unsustainable. Wind power facilities will consume more than 3 times the amount of energy needed to design, fabricate, erect, operate, maintain and decommission than they will ever produce. Wind power is a collosal waste of resources.

    Get the facts.

    Considering you can download the book for about $6 it might be worth a look for those who want some technical background on generation.

  9. Scientific American published an article on the dangers of installing solar panels on your house or barns. If not properly installed or something goes wrong with them they can start a fire or electrocute someone.

    The article said solar panel owners may be asked to carry extra insurance on your buildings.

  10. Solar panels are more complicated than many household electronics which many people struggle to deal with. It will be surprising to see most solar units make it past the 10 year mark. Most will never get to pay back. If a person was trying to get off the grid go for it and good luck. If a person is planning to make money they will need more than luck.

  11. Generating enough electricity for a house is not an amateur activity but many people think it is.

    Makes me wonder if the solar panels out in farm fields and left unprotected are safe?

Comments are closed.