Turtles vs turbines case goes to court

blandings_turtleToronto Star
Blanding’s turtles get their day in court this week – three days, in fact – as a case that pits turtles against wind turbines enters a new phase. The turtles won the first round last year, when an environmental review tribunal blocked a proposal to erect nine turbines on the shore of Lake Ontario at Ostrander Point in Prince Edward County.

The reason: The tribunal ruled that new roads built for access to the turbines would cause “serious and irreversible harm” to the local population of Blanding’s turtles, a threatened species. After hearing arguments from the Prince Edward County Field Naturalists club, the tribunal revoked the renewable energy permit that wind developer Gilead Power had previously been granted.

The case highlighted the tensions that have developed between some environmentalists and the wind energy industry. Tuesday the wind power company, Gilead Power, and Ontario’s ministry of the environment were in divisional court to appeal the ruling. Read article

2 thoughts on “Turtles vs turbines case goes to court

  1. Was the Blanding’s turtle status changed from endangered to at risk since the Ostrander Point ERT decision?

  2. Nature Canada
    Blanding’s turtle
    Status under SARA: Endangered, Threatened
    “In Ontario there are many educational and outreach programs, but no formal action plan for species protection and recovery exists.”
    http://www.naturecanada.ca

    SARA/Species At Risk Act
    Species Profile
    Blanding’s Turtle Great Lakes/St.Lawerence Population
    Scroll down Threats & Protection
    This is federal level information.
    http://www.sararegistry.gc.ca/species/speciesDetails_e.cfm?sid=846

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *